Our antique shop is located along the Susquehanna River at the mouth of Goodyear Lake just south of Cooperstown, New York. Originally built as a Gristmill in the late 1790s, it has housed only two other occupations; a feed and grain store which operated until the early 1960s, and the Blue Bonnnet antique shop run by Mr. & Mrs. Damon for 30 plus years. In 2009 the building was purchased by Sue Jarema and Nick Sanna and is again an antiques shop, but this time with a twist.

Today it is a Multi-Dealer Antique and Collectible shop. As such, there is a wide variety of items to choose from as each dealer puts their own spin and special design on their individual spaces. And we have some of the finest antiques and collectibles in the region at reasonable prices.

The building itself is like walking back in time, especially if you enjoy history. With it's incredible hand hewn beams, a back porch that literally hangs over the Susquehanna River, and all of the incredible antiques inside, you simply can't go wrong when you stop by for a visit.

Payment Options

  • Discover, Personal Checks, Debit Cards, MasterCard, VISA

Contact Details

  Website
  Person Old Gristmill Antiques & Collectibles
  City Portlandville , NY
  Zip Code 13834
  Address 2838 State Highway 28
  Phone Number (607) 441-3152